New York is known for being tough. We have some of the strictest laws in the country. This is especially true when it comes to owning guns. At the same time, New York has become very open to cannabis. The state wants people to have access to natural medicine. This creates a very confusing situation for residents. Many people who enjoy hunting or sport shooting also have health issues. They want to know if they can treat their pain without losing their rights. The big question is, can MMJ cardholders buy guns in New York safely?
The answer is a mix of “yes” and “no.” New York state law tries to protect you. But the federal government stands in the way.
In this guide, we will break it all down. We will keep it simple so you can understand your rights. Let’s explore how the Empire State handles guns and green medicine.
The Federal Hurdle
Before we talk about New York, we have to look at the big picture. The United States government makes laws for the whole country. They have a very strict view on drugs.
The main law is called the Gun Control Act of 1968. This law decides who is allowed to own a firearm. It has a list of people who are banned from owning guns.
One of the groups on that “banned” list is “unlawful users” of controlled substances. To the federal government, marijuana is still a controlled substance.
It does not matter if New York says it is legal. The federal government treats cannabis the same way they treat dangerous street drugs. This creates a major problem for patients.
The ATF Form 4473 “Trap”
The real trouble starts when you walk into a gun store. If you want to buy a firearm from a dealer, you must fill out a form. This is the ATF Form 4473.
This is a federal background check form. It asks you a lot of personal questions. Question 21g is the one you need to watch out for.
It asks if you are an unlawful user of marijuana.
It warns you that marijuana is illegal under federal law.
It explicitly states that state legalization does not count.
Here is why this is a trap:
-
If you say “Yes”: The dealer cannot sell you the gun.
-
If you say “No”: But you have a medical card, you are lying.
-
The Result: Lying on this form is a federal felony called perjury.
Because of this form, the answer to Can MMJ Card Holders Buy Guns in New York is technically “no” at the point of sale.
New York State Law: The MRTA Protection
Now for some good news. New York State has passed laws to help you. In 2021, the state passed the Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act (MRTA).
This law did more than just legalize weed. It created specific protections for people who use cannabis. The lawmakers wanted to make sure you are treated fairly.
The MRTA says that you cannot be discriminated against just for using cannabis. This applies to housing, jobs, and even some licenses.
It specifically addresses your civil rights. The state wants you to be able to use your medicine without fear. This is a big step forward for patient rights.
Protections for Pistol Permits
In New York, you usually need a permit to own a handgun. Getting a pistol permit can be a long and hard process. You have to prove you are responsible.
Under the MRTA, using medical marijuana is not a crime. Therefore, it should not be the only reason a judge denies your permit.
Here is what the MRTA protections mean for you:
-
No Automatic Denial: The state cannot reject your application just because you are a patient.
-
Legal Conduct: Using medical cannabis is considered “lawful conduct” in New York.
-
Rights Protection: The law says you should not lose privileges solely based on cannabis use.
So, under state law, Can MMJ Card Holders Buy Guns in New York? The state government implies that you should be able to. However, the federal rules still apply at the gun store.
The Conflict: Buying vs. Possessing
This creates a very strange situation. We often call this a “Catch-22.” It means you are stuck between two conflicting rules.
New York State says, “Here is your permit, you are fine.”
The Federal Government says, “If you try to buy a gun, we will stop you.”
You might be able to keep the guns you already own. New York is not sending police to take guns away from patients. The protections in the MRTA help with possession.
But buying a new gun is where you hit a wall. You cannot get around the federal background check.
The NICS Background Check System
When you buy a gun, the store calls the FBI. They use a system called NICS (National Instant Criminal Background Check System).
This system checks to see if you are eligible. If you admitted to using drugs on the form, the system denies you.
-
Federal Firearms Licensees (FFL): Gun stores are licensed by the federal government.
-
Their Duty: They must follow federal rules, not just state rules.
-
The Reality: Even with a NY permit, the store might refuse you if they know you use cannabis.
This makes purchasing very difficult. You have the right to own it under state law, but no legal way to buy it under federal law.
Getting Your Medical Card: Prioritizing Health
Life is about choices. For many New Yorkers, health is the most important thing. Living with chronic pain, anxiety, or insomnia is terrible.
Medical cannabis can change your life. It offers relief when other medicines fail. If you are suffering, you should not let politics stop you from healing.
Getting your card is easier than ever. You do not need to go to a doctor’s office. You can do it all from home.
This is where Kif Doctors comes in. We are a leading telehealth service. We connect you with doctors who care.
Our experienced medical staff understands the laws. We provide a safe and private space for your evaluation. We believe you deserve to feel better.
Healthcare in New York can be expensive. We want to make sure everyone can afford their medicine. We have created a special offer just for you.
Check out this simple deal: See our transparent costs here.
Get your full evaluation for just $99/year.
-
We offer Instant Approval if you qualify for the program.
-
Risk-Free: If you are not approved, you get your money back.
Don’t overpay for your health. Use our transparent costs plan and get your card today!
Risks and Disclaimers
We want you to be safe. We are medical experts, not lawyers. This blog is here to help you learn, but it is not legal advice.
New York is a complicated place for gun owners. Even with the MRTA, there are risks. You need to be careful.
New York’s “Good Moral Character” Clause
There is one more thing to watch out for. When you apply for a pistol permit in NY, they look at your “moral character.”
This is a vague term. It lets judges and police officers make their own decisions.
-
Local Discretion: A judge in one county might be cool with cannabis. A judge in another county might hate it.
-
The Risk: A strict judge might say that violating federal law (by using cannabis) shows “bad moral character.”
- No Guarantees: Even with the MRTA, a judge could still try to deny you.It is always smart to talk to a lawyer. Find an attorney in New York who knows about the NY SAFE Act and the MRTA. They can give you the best advice for your town.
Conclusion
New York is trying to move forward. The MRTA laws are a great step for protecting patients. But the federal government is still stuck in the past.
So, can MMJ cardholders buy guns in New York?
-
State Law: Yes, you are protected from discrimination.
-
Federal Law: No, you cannot pass the purchase background check.
You have to decide what matters most to you. Is it buying a new hunting rifle? Or is it getting relief from your pain?
For thousands of our patients, the relief is worth it. Health is the foundation of a good life.If you are ready to start your journey, we are here to help. You can get certified today online. It is fast, private, and secure.
Authentic Sources
- New York Senate: The Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act (MRTA) Legislation
- Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives: Federal Firearms Regulations Reference Guide
- New York State Police: Firearms / Pistol Permit Information
